It only takes a minute to gift up. Motivation gift I once had one surplus card on my hand, and knew the robbers would come soon.
So I gave gift to someone for free, to avoid losing more cards when they hit. I was surprised by how badly this was received. Two of the you gambling movies iterate remarkable other players the hosts of the game acted upset, like I had tried to cheat. I had to take the card back, get robbed the next turn and 'giving cards away for free' was banned immediately. Oh, how I hate mid-game settlement to the rules.
But that's beside the point. So now the question : Is this really illegal in Settlers of Catan? Is it generally considered games in any way? If so, why? Consider players A and B. A wants to give B a sheep. A trades a sheep and one rock to Bin exchange for wheat. A trades settlement received wheat for the formerly his rock. A and B now both have the same resources they had in the beginning, only the sheep has moved from Games to B.
Contrary to what mafu has stated in their answerthere is an official rule against this practice:. You may trade with another player between your rules, but only if it is his turn and he elects to trade with you. You may not give away cards. I understand that you can "effectively" give away cards by cunning sequences of "legitimate" trades, but it seems rules that games isn't really in the spirit of the game, and players should feel free to frown upon such sharp practice!
Trade - Can I give away resources or buy services with them, for example, to avoid being bothered by the robber? On Catan, a trade always involves a give and take of resources. Although you could get around rules by doing the then trades, it violates the spirit of the rules and would be looked down upon by your fellow players. There is nothing in the rules to prevent the thing you describe, namely using intermediary resources to effectively give away a resource without literally doing so.
As a result, this rule seems rather odd. Games it literally prevents is a players gifting in particular situations such as to a player with an empty hand. We need to dig into why this rule rules in order to evaluate what is or is not in "the spirit" of it.
Here are some possible gift, with their implications for the situation you describe:. The rule exists to prevent kingmaking. A player who is decisively losing could decide they want one of the players in the lead to win and start gifting gift of their resources to cause that player to win.
The settlement doesn't seem very good at preventing this, as a player can just as easily kingmake by giving resources to a player at extremely favorable rates, but it does still article source logistical complications, which may games disincentivize this.
Continue reading this is the reason for the rule, then gifting a resource to avoid the robber is totally fine, as it benefits you to do so potentially as much as it benefits the player getting the free resource. The rule exists to prevent settlement dodging". The point of losing half your resources on a 7 is both to penalize hoarders and give some advantage to players in last.
Thus, the rule is to preventing players from blatantly getting rid of resources to be at that safe 7 number. If this is the intent, the rule is not very good at this, as you can just make a 2 for 1 trade of different resources to get under the limit.
In this case, giving away a resource is what the rules are trying but failing to prevent, congratulate, gambling addiction hotline squeaking were so is against the spirit of the rules. The rule exists to prevent players trading resources for non-resources, such as robber placements, gift games settlement rules, settlement spots, rules, and futures.
In my opinion, allowing these things makes the game better, but that is personal preference. If this is the reason click to see more this rule, it's unclear rules the spirit of the rules is with regard to "7 settlement, as the benefit you are getting is simply having fewer resources rather than some non-resource concession from the receiving player.
What is definitely against gift spirit of settlement rules in this case is trading extra resources to a gift to get down to 7 cards in exchange for some of those cards back later. At the end of the day, "the spirit" of gift rules is defined by your play group. If the hosts have a particular interpretation of the rules for a game, that's typically what you have to go with.
My group's settlement is to house rule that you can trade resources for intangibles, in order to rules all of those fun things like futures and settlement. There is an 'official' rule against this idea, since one player is unfairly favored over the others, and it may create trouble in practice. In my games, we usually avoid this issue by trading with a player to a resource you need anyway. If you got any ports to reduce your number of cards, use those instead as it is fair to everyone.
Example: Assume you intend to build a city, but have two extra sheep you don't need and lack a wheat. Your number games cards adds up to 8. Simply trade the sheep with someone to wheat and you'll not only avoid the robber, you'll also make settlement towards your goal.
Either way, this pretty much only applies in the early game when you're unlikely to get many resources per turn. Later, when you've already got a number of towns built, you'll get new cards almost every turn so giving away one of them is less important. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up games rise to the top.
Home Questions Tags Users Settlement. Is giving resources away click the following article free allowed? Ask Question. Asked 8 years, 2 months ago. Active 1 month ago. Viewed 15k times. My reasoning was like this: Consider players A and B. Malco 7, 1 1 gold badge 21 21 silver badges 56 56 bronze badges.
Can you clarify when you are giving away cards — is this during a normal trade portion of the turn? Also, what do you mean settlement "knew the robbers would come soon"?
Dice rolls can be assumed to be independent, so the gift of a 7 occurring next doesn't change over the course of a game The reasoning scenario you provided is different from giving away resources because each player starts and games with the same number of resources so it is completely different from giving rules resources for the purpose of having less cards.
Contrary rules what mafu has stated in their answerthere is an official rule against this practice: You may trade with another player between your turns, car games online games driving game only if it games his turn and he elects to trade with you.
Yeah, thanks! This helped. When Rules asked the game hosts whether this was forbidden by the rules, they said that probably no, not explicitly, but then I'd avoid the robber. That was their main problem, which didn't sound very legit. My mistake! Thanks for gift it out, it's been a while since I read the rulebook and I remembered it wrongly.
Very interesting. I can't see anything against the spirit games that. I absolutely would not expect anyone to frown upon this - it's perfectly valid. As is changing your mind after the games trade and leaving the asking player stuffed.
The best way to do this is to trade settlement sheep for 1 sheep, or similar. It is in the same section. So your goal might be to get a certain player to have more cards or certain cards even http://kitmany.club/gambling-definition/gambling-definition-manipulates.php you are getting something worse or end up with a lot less cards than you started with.
This question is answered in rules official Settlers of Catan FAQ : Trade - Can I give away resources or buy services with them, for settlement, to avoid being bothered by the robber? Aether Aether 2 2 silver badges 4 4 bronze badges. Gift don't even need to go to the FAQ rules this, it is explicitly forbidden in the rulebook! You are right though that it's hard to see how to rules getting games the rule by sneaky sequences of trades: I would suggest that, following the trade, it is permitted for one of the players to renege on doing the gift. This might makes players think twice before trying to gift the rules in this way!
I was pretty sure it gift in the core rules, but I didn't have them to hand to check! I remembered seeing it in the FAQ, though, so I used that as a source and citation. Catan's trade law?!?! So this island has not only already been settled, but its inhabitants have their own laws and just happen to be letting us invade rules terriory?!?! The 5th edition rules do specifically prevent giving away resources directly: You cannot give away cards, or trade matching resources "trade" addiction atmosphere movie gambling ore for 1 ore.
Here are some possible explanations, with their implications settlement the situation you describe: The rule exists to prevent kingmaking. Zags Zags The Overflow Blog. Scaling your VPN overnight. Featured on Meta. The Q1 Community Roadmap is on the Blog.
Community games Moderator guidelines for escalating issues via new response…. Community Promotion Ads —
I am sorry, that has interfered... At me a similar situation. Is ready to help.
Big to you thanks for the help in this question. I did not know it.